20 Years On, Katrina Doc “Trouble the Water” Is Tragically Relevant

August 29, 2025 marked the 20th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina making landfall in New Orleans, irrevocably altering the iconic city and its population. That storm also changed the landscape of Americans’ relationship with their government. For thousands of Gulf Coast residents, the safety nets weren’t just “inadequate;” they were completely absent (even before the hurricane struck). Katrina slammed into the city with a vengeance: sustained winds were measured at around 145 MPH. And then the levees broke…

Tia Lessin and Carl Deal released their award-winning documentary film Trouble the Water in 2008, three years after Hurricane Katrina struck the Gulf Coast and moved inland, leaving untold devastation in its wake. Their film begins with a look at New Orleans on September 14, 2005 — two weeks later — opening with a montage of still and moving images underscored by audio clips that deepen the impact. Among the chorus of voices, we hear that of then-President George W. Bush who infamously claimed: “I don’t think anybody anticipated the breach of the levees.”

Of course, we know now that the magnitude of the storm was matched or surpassed only by the failure of the municipal, state, and federal governments to support poor and Black residents from Florida to Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, and Tennessee before, during, and after Katrina. NPR reporter Lynn Neary observed in 2006: “A year ago, we all watched as the catastrophe that was Katrina unfolded on national media. Searing images showing that most of those left behind to cope with the disaster were poor and Black which forced the nation to confront an issue that has long haunted us: racism and the poverty that accompanies it.”

Even as millions of us watched news coverage of frantic people pleading for help from rooftops, the shocking conditions of the mass shelter at the Superdome, and the frequently menacing presence of military and law enforcement personnel who should have been rendering aid, but instead largely chose suspicion over empathy, there developed a discourse of denial of systemic racism.

Even as millions of us watched news coverage of frantic people pleading for help from rooftops, the shocking conditions of the mass shelter at the Superdome, and the frequently menacing presence of military and law enforcement personnel who should have been rendering aid, but instead largely chose suspicion over empathy, there developed a discourse of denial of systemic racism.

“Poll data showed,” write Glenn Adams, Laurie T. O’Brien, and Jessica C. Nelson in their study, “Perceptions of Racism in Hurricane Katrina: A Liberation Psychology Analysis” (Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, Vol. 6, No. 1, 2006, pp. 215—235) “that African Americans perceived more racism in the response to Hurricane Katrina than did White Americans.” “White Americans,” they explain, “may perceive less racism in the Katrina disaster because they are less likely than African Americans to know about historically documented acts of past racism.”

In other words, Black Americans’ perspectives on racism are informed by lifelong, first- person experience. As such, they must remain constantly vigilant in the face of systemic racism whereas White Americans have much to gain by denying instances of racism rather than acknowledging them, thereby threatening “the legitimacy of the status quo.”

Trouble the Water takes us front and center to the experiences of Black residents of New Orleans’ Lower Ninth Ward, an area of the city that is predominantly Black and profoundly poor. Even before Katrina, the neighborhoods of the Lower Ninth Ward were marked by long-term underdevelopment.

Kimberly Rivers Roberts, one New Orleanian who lives in the Lower Ninth Ward, immediately emerges as the central figure in Trouble the Water. Kim (a 24-year-old rap artist who goes by the name “Black Kold Madina”) along with her husband, Scott Roberts, their two dogs, and a and cat all remained in their home despite the evacuation order because they lacked the means to leave: they didn’t have a vehicle — Kim’s car had been stolen the week prior to Katrina — nor did they know anyone who could transport them to a temporary shelter such as the Superdome. “If I could have left, I would have,” Kim says. “But there was no way.”

People were told they were supposed to leave New Orleans, but at least 100,000 did not… because they didn’t have the resources…

“People were told they were supposed to leave New Orleans, but at least 100,000 did not, and research has revealed that in most cases, they didn’t evacuate because they didn’t have the resources,” Lisa Marshall, Associate Director of Science Storytelling at the University of Colorado, Boulder explains. “It was the end of the month, and many people reported they didn’t have money for gas or they didn’t have a car,” said Marshall. Others were caring for elders or children. New Orleans also had one of the highest disability rates in the country, and some couldn’t get access to transportation or couldn’t leave without their caregiver.

In the course of Trouble the Water, video footage taken by Kim (who is learning to use her new video camera) provides a potent, firsthand view of the horror the forgotten New Orleanians of the Lower Ninth Ward (among others) faced. The contributions of Kim and Scott — as well as their family, friends, and neighbors — pervade this documentary with unflinching honesty and impact.

Prior to Katrina, the population of the Lower Ninth Ward was about 14,000. In 2023, the population was a little over 5,000. That’s a devastating population decrease of 65%. Even now, rebuilding efforts have been woefully insufficient compared to those in White, more affluent, and touristic areas of the city.

According to a 2006 article by Manuel Pastor, Robert Bullard, James K.Boyce, Alice Fothergill, Rachel Morello-Frosch, and Beverly Wright, “Environment, Disaster, and Race After Katrina,” the pre-Katrina Black population in New Orleans was about 67%. One year later, it was 35 to 40% at the most. “Around the time of Katrina,” they note, “poor Blacks were much less likely to have access to cars than even poor Whites, 53 versus 17 percent.”

The stage for disaster was set by pre-Katrina systemic vulnerabilities rooted in segregation and poverty.

The stage for disaster was set by pre-Katrina systemic vulnerabilities rooted in segregation and poverty. For example, Black New Orleanians were far more likely to reside in low-lying neighborhoods, which were the most flood prone. Infrastructure was inadequate and far from resilient. Indeed, the US Army Corps of Engineers, in charge of maintaining the levees, are now known to have prioritized flood control in more affluent, White communities.

As Trouble the Water unfolds, the glaring racial and economic disparities with respect to evacuation options are emphasized by footage of Kim’s neighbor, Larry, who rescues Lower Ninth Ward residents left behind (including elderly and disabled people and children trapped in attics, on roofs, and elsewhere). Unbelievably, Larry uses a punching bag from a boxing gym as a flotation device to facilitate the rescues. Later, he acquires a small rowboat.

In contrast to the valiant efforts of people like Larry, Scott, and Kim (who shared food and shelter with neighbors) rescue and recovery efforts at all levels of government imposed further obstacles for thousands of already beleaguered New Orleanians. Then we are witnesses as Kim, Scott, their family members, and friends, despair at the infuriatingly complex processes of applying for and receiving aid from FEMA. The obstacles seem deliberate. Like thousands of other residents of the ravaged city, Scott and Kim attempt to relocate — in their case to Memphis (TN) — only to be met with a daunting and expensive a process. Ultimately, they return home to New Orleans.

Through the course of Trouble the Water, Kim, among other interviewees, speaks often of self-reliance and resilience, and we witness it over and over again as the film proceeds. Yet, it must be said that this is to an extent the language of the abandoned.

One of the most excruciating moments in Trouble the Water is when an elderly woman — trapped in her attic above the rising water — calls 911 for help.

One of the most excruciating moments in Trouble the Water is when an elderly woman — trapped in her attic above the rising water — calls 911 for help. We hear the audio. We never see her. The dispatcher asks her if she can punch a hole in the attic and climb up onto the roof. The woman explains that she has tried, but she simply can’t remove the physical material. Then she says, “So, I’m going to die?” It’s far more a statement than a question. The dispatcher is silent at first. The pause is heartbreaking. Then comes the dispatcher’s barely audible reply: “I’m sorry.”

When Kim and Scott return to their neighborhood on September 14, authorities still have not searched most of the neighborhood homes for either survivors or bodies. They discover that one of Kim’s relatives — an addict whom everyone knew and had tried to look after — had perished alone in a home where he had sought shelter.

For thousands of poor and non-White New Orleanians, starting over in the face of the colossal odds of systemic racism and poverty — which was exacerbated by relentless, post-Katrina gentrification efforts — was and remains “daunting” (to put it mildly).

20 years after Katrina, Tia and Carl’s film Trouble the Water remains tragically relevant.

20 years after Katrina, Tia and Carl’s film Trouble the Water remains tragically relevant. Writing for CNBC in July 2025, Scott Cohn reports, “America’s infrastructure, long the butt of jokes and the subject of political wrangling that seemed to go nowhere, has just received its best grade ever in the American Society of Civil Engineers’ annual infrastructure Report Card.” The overall grade was a “C,” up from a “C-.”

Infrastructure encompasses things like bridges, roads, ports, airports, utilities, sustainability, and connectivity. While the nation overall got a “C,” several states have, notes Cohn, “barely made a dent in their infrastructure problems.” Coming in fifth worst on that list is Louisiana (the home of Mike Johnson, the current Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives). Coupled with increasingly erratic weather, including powerful storms, provoked by worsening climate change, New Orleans, among many other American cities, remains vulnerable.

Trouble the Water — which was distributed by Zeitgeist Films — won numerous awards, beginning with the Grand Jury Prize at the 2008 Sundance Film Festival, and continuing with the Kathleen Bryan Edwards Award for Human Rights, the Working Films Award at the 2008 Full Frame Documentary Film Festival, the Special Jury Prize at the 2008 AFI Docs festival, the Gotham Award for best documentary, and the Council on Foundation’s Henry Hampton Award. All of these interim accolades brought them to Los Angeles in 2009 where Trouble the Water was one of the five Best Documentary candidates at the 81st Academy Awards!

As they state on their website, Tia and Carl “create documentary films of cultural relevance, social purpose and artistic integrity.”

In addition to Trouble the Water, Tia and Carl (who co-founded Elsewhere Films in 2007), also directed and produced (along with Gillian Caldwell) Citizen Koch in 2013. “Citizen Koch” examines the emergence of the Tea Party, which many argue “laid the foundation for the election of Donald Trump.” They’ve also produced a number of Michael Moore’s films, namely, Fahrenheit 9/11, Bowling for Columbine, Capitalism: A Love Story, and Where to Invade Next. As they state on their website, Tia and Carl “create documentary films of cultural relevance, social purpose and artistic integrity.”

Tia, in collaboration with Emma Pildes, also directed the documentary, The Janes, which ran on HBO and won three Emmys. Tia’s resume is extensive and impressive. We’re looking forward to the release of her upcoming documentary, Steal This Story, Please, which recounts the story of iconic independent journalist Amy Goodman of Democracy Now.

Lately, Kim is releasing a new documentary — Fear No Gumbo — which she plans to release by the end of 2025. In Fear No Gumbo, Kim explores a juvenile detention center adjacent to a high school in the Lower Ninth Ward as well as the exploitation of local Black artists. According to her, Fear No Gumbo is meant to show that Katrina is still alive and well. She’s still interrupting quality of life for citizens of New Orleans who are not middle class and rich.

© Debra Thimmesch (8/29/25) – Special for FF2 Media

LEARN MORE/DO MORE

Read about Tia Lessin and Carl Deal here.

Watch the Trouble the Water trailer here.

Read Lisa Marshall’s full article here.

Read the “Perceptions of Racism in Hurricane Katrina: A Liberation Psychology Analysis” study here.

Review this 2006 article, “Environment, Disaster, and Race After Katrina” here.

Read Scott Cohn’s CNBC article on 10 States that have the worst infrastructure in America here.

Access the American Society of Civil Engineers’ annual Infrastructure Report Card here.

Stay up-to-date with the progress of Tia’s upcoming documentary Steal This Story, Please here.

Watch Kimberly Rivers-Roberts’ interview on Fear No Gumbo here.

CREDITS & PERMISSIONS

Featured Photo: Tia Lessin accepts the award for Grand Jury Prize in the Documentary category for the film Trouble the Water at the Sundance Film Festival awards ceremony at the Racquet Club Theater in Park City, Utah on January 26, 2008. (UPI Photo/Alexis C. Glenn). Alamy Image ID: W00CWA

Middle Photo: Upper level of a residential house in Biloxi (MS), amidst wreckage in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Alamy Image ID: CN4B7T

Bottom Photo: Photo of Kim and Scott (with their dogs!) was received by Jan Lisa Huttner from Tia’s publicist as part of the original EPK prepared by Zeitgeist Films. Read Jan’s full 5-star review: “A triumph of documentary filmmaking, sure to be a contender as ’09 Oscar buzz builds. (JLH: 5/5).

Exit Photo: Honorees at the 81st annual Academy Awards ceremony include Kim, Scott, Tia, Carl, and Executive Producer Danny Glover. Los Angeles (2/21/09). Alamy Image ID: GBF7FA (Editor’s Note: In 2022, AMPAS also presented Danny Glover with its prestigious Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award, honoring his extraordinary career as an actor and producer.)

Tags: Amy Goodman, Citizen Koch, Climate Change, Fear No Gumbo, female oscar nominees, Hurricane Katrina, Kimberly Rivers Roberts, new orleans, Systemic racism, The Janes, Tia Lessin, Trouble the Water, Women Oscar Nominees

Related Posts

by
Debra Thimmesch is an art historian and critic, activist, independent researcher and scholar, writer, editor, and visual artist. She mentors graduate students in art history and is attuned to current endeavors to radically rethink, decolonize, and reframe the study and pedagogy of art history. Her work has appeared in Art Papers, The Brooklyn Rail, and Blind Field Journal.
Previous Post Next Post