Agnieszka Holland’s Controversial No-Man’s-Land: Green Border

A young girl stands behind a barbed wire fence in Green Border.

You needn’t have a sophisticated grasp of the complex geopolitics of Eastern Europe, the EU, or NATO to experience the powerful impact of Polish director Agnieszka Holland’s controversial 2023 film, Green Border. The fundamentally, starkly human tenor of Green Border’s narrative transcends particularities; that is, this tragedy could be unfolding almost anywhere, at any given moment, anywhere in the world, on any given border. What you absolutely must arrive equipped with are a conscience and an abundance of physical and emotional stamina as the film is two-and-a-half hours long and it’s raw.

Phenomenally, Agnieszka and co-writers Gabriela Łazarkiewicz-Sieczko and Maciej Pisuk infuse every moment of Green Border with a sense of the magnitude of the issues particular to the stories of individual characters, which are in many cases interwoven, albeit involuntarily. 

In its essence, the film feels documentary and is, according to its director, based on real events and characters “but composed” (Vulture). Notably, however, the cast included African and Syrian actors who had themselves made the harrowing journey from their homelands, seeking asylum.

As to the matter of authenticity, Green Border’s depiction of the systematic dehumanization of a people, the indignities and atrocities inflicted upon them, the loss and grief, and the hope and compassion, are all too real. Therefore, those 150 minutes pass eventfully – and often excruciatingly slowly until you cannot help but look away.

Green Border‘s opening moments

Despite its chromatic title, Green Border unfolds entirely in black and white. Besides providing the director and cinematographer with a rich field for heightening dramatic impact via lighting choices, in more literal terms this binary aesthetic underlines the matter of race at the heart of the film. Eliminating color also prevents unintended symbolic and metaphorical interpretations rooted in certain colors (consider, for instance, the heartbreaking lapses into targeted color in Schindler’s List).  

Agnieszka introduces us to some of the movie’s central characters in the opening scene. A Syrian family, Bashir (Jalal Altawil), his wife Amina (Dalia Naous), and their three children, including an infant son, and Bashir’s father (Al Rashi Mohamad), are on a flight from Turkey to Belarus. They’ve been led to believe they will be able to gain entry from Belarus to the EU via Poland with relative ease. From Poland, Bashir and family intend to make the trek to join his brother in Sweden. They encounter another refugee on the flight and she joins their party at the airport. Here, the audience is introduced to Leïla, a middle-aged teacher who is fleeing Afghanistan and a pivotal character in the story.

There is a moment when the women and girls on the flight are gifted with roses by the flight crew and welcomed to Belarus. It is like the last vestiges of sunlight in a film that relies on near darkness not merely to heighten emotional effect. However, it provides viewers with a mere glimpse of what their imminent time in the forest – the green border – is going to be like. 

For immigrants, the necessity of setting aside skepticism and fear is essential or one might remain forever immobilized. However, the hopefulness of the refugees in Green Border, at least for those of us watching from a position of relative privilege, comes across as alarming naïveté. Or, perhaps that’s the tightrope between desperation and aspiration that Agnieszka’s cast of emigres traverse? Indeed, one of the most distressing aspects of the film is observing the characters shed hope. It is reminiscent of the personal belongings they’re forced to leave behind or that are violently taken from them.

Maja Ostaszewska in Green Border.
Click image to enlarge.

Darkness as a symbol of subterfuge, ignorance

The calculated darkness of the film is symbolic of subterfuge and, if not evil, acute and often willful ignorance. The impact of this cinematographic choice is perhaps felt most profoundly when we’re privy to the spaces dominated by men, particularly the murky terrain between and on either side of the border. Also in darkness, in the forest at night, the refugees hide from police and wild animals and light is the enemy; we hear them more than we see them. Each morning, the light brings increasingly uglier truths. 

With Green Border, Agnieszka provides viewers with a survey of the process by which a person is dehumanized – or, more accurately, an entire people are dehumanized. This is a complex dynamic that transforms the human trafficker, the border guard, the activist, the private citizen, and the refugee alike. If you’ve asked the question, “How did everyday people let that happen?” concerning genocide, then perhaps you’ll receive some insights here. That’s the hope. 

The Syrian and Afghani refugees are grouped involuntarily with others such as a pregnant young Somali woman (Joely Mbundu), and her husband. As they are forced by guards with guns and dogs under the barbed wire to Poland and then back again to Belarus in a game of ultra-violent political football, we are spectators to the intricate savagery of the dehumanization process in action. Striking personal vignettes drive home the point but also function to reassert the humanity of a given character. For instance, we witness the despair of Amina when she can no longer breastfeed her frantic baby and we recoil at the damaged feet of the grandfather. And so on. 

Agnieszka’s use of concurrent narratives

Agnieszka establishes concurrent narratives early in the film: those of the Polish border police and their racist-propaganda-spouting commander, activists who must toe the line legally as they provide aid to the refugees, and an assortment of other concerned or, conversely, ambivalent (at best) private Polish citizens. 

As the refugees are jettisoned brutally into the no man’s land between the two borders, the lives of Polish border guard, Jan (Tomasz Wlosok), and his pregnant wife, Kasia (Malwina Buss), come into focus. Jan’s conscience becomes increasingly at odds with his sense of duty. Meanwhile, Julia (Maja Ostaszewska), a psychologist living close to the border and one of her virtual clients, Bogdan (Maciej Stuhr), become serendipitous and subversive partners in the drama, drawn in quite by accident by one of the lead activists, Ula (Marta Stalmierska).

Green Border is not a tale of anyone’s redemption, although there are moments of supreme mercy and tenderness. Is it possible to appeal to the better nature of people who think nothing of perpetrating the kind of horrors portrayed in the film and, more importantly, in real life? I think not. Rather, Agnieszka issues a very public plea to governments, to humanitarian organizations, and to everyday people: something must be done urgently. 

Green Border controversy

The controversy sparked by Green Border well before its release is a testament to volatility of the subject. In particular, a bellicose condemnation was issued by the right-wing Polish government following the film’s premiere at the Venice Film Festival. It was awarded the special jury prize, which garnered its makers international notoriety. The Polish Minister of Justice, Abigniew Ziobro, compared it to “Nazi propaganda” and President Andrzej Duda, also reaching back to World War II propaganda, declared, “Only pigs sit in cinemas.” 

The situation escalated and Agnieszka was denounced by Poland’s right-wing nationalist party; she has also received multiple death threats. Not to be deterred, the seasoned director resorted to filming in undisclosed locations, assigning sections of the script to two different associate directions. So contentious was the subject of the Polish government’s persecution of certain immigrants, she didn’t dare appeal to the Polish Film Institute for financial support. 

Agnieszka Holland’s filmography and legacy

A quick glance at her filmography emphasizes that 75-year-old Agnieszka has never shied away from controversy or from grappling with the ugly or even horrific side of human behavior and history. Having fled Poland herself in the tumultuous 1980s, she’s also no stranger to the plight of the refugee. 

However, the dissension sowed by Green Border was magnified when, with the film’s epilogue, she pointed out the disparity between Poland’s acceptance of primarily white Ukrainian refugees and its treatment of non-white Middle Eastern and African would-be emigres. 

The film closes with faux-documentary footage of asylum seekers crossing from Ukraine into Poland. They are ushered onto buses by Polish volunteers, including the activist, Ula, whom we met earlier. The mostly women and children coming from Ukraine carry pets and personal belongings; they weep – as one would – at having been uprooted, no less by war. 

It’s a heartrending scene. It’s the sort of humanitarian effort one would hope to see under such circumstances, and a far cry from the horrors we’ve just witnessed during the preceding two-and-a-half hours.

© Debra Thimmesch (7/14/24) – Special for FF2 Media

Polish director Agnieszka Holland attends the red carpet for the movie 'Zielona Granica (Green Border)' at the 80th Venice International Film Festival on September 5, 2023 in Venice, Italy.

LEARN MORE/DO MORE

Watch the trailer for Green Border.

Agnieszka Holland stops by Democracy Now! to chat about the film.

Read Vulture’s interview with Agnieszka Holland at the Venice Film Festival.

CREDITS & PERMISSIONS

Featured photo: A child stands behind a barbed wire fence in Green Border. Image obtained from the film’s electronic press kit.

Middle photo: Maja Ostaszewska in Green Border. Image obtained from the film’s electronic press kit.

Bottom photo: The Polish director Agnieszka Holland attends the red carpet for Green Border at the 80th Venice International Film Festival on September 5, 2023 in Venice, Italy. Photo © Ottavia Da Re/Sintesi/Alamy Live News. Image ID: 2RPR0BX

Tags: Agnieszka Holland, Al Rashi Mohamad, Dalia Naous, film review, Gabriela Łazarkiewicz-Sieczko, Green Border, Jalal Altawil, Maciej Pisuk, Polland, Venice Film Festival

Related Posts

by
Debra Thimmesch is an art historian and critic, activist, independent researcher and scholar, writer, editor, and visual artist. She mentors graduate students in art history and is attuned to current endeavors to radically rethink, decolonize, and reframe the study and pedagogy of art history. Her work has appeared in Art Papers, The Brooklyn Rail, and Blind Field Journal.
Previous Post Next Post